Versions Compared

Key

  • This line was added.
  • This line was removed.
  • Formatting was changed.

...

  • The following explanations assume Private CA-signed certificates Certificates or selfPublic CA-signed certificates Certificates to be used.
    • Private CA-signed Certificates are created by users who operate their own CA, see the JS7 - How to create X.509 SSL TLS Certificates.
    • Public CA-signed certificates Certificates are provided from known and trusted Certificate Authorities (CA) that validate the domain owner.
    • Self-signed certificates are created by users who operate their own CA, see the JS7 - How to create self-signed Certificates.
    • Use of Intermediate CA Certificates is optional.
    • There is no difference in using a Private CA or Public CA concerning functionality of X.509 certificates, usage for Server Authentication / Client Authentication, or security of connections. The only difference is that users trust the Private CA that they set up on their ownUse of Intermediate CA Certificates is optional.
  • Certificate stores can be managed from the command line and by use of tools that provide a GUI for this purpose:
    • the Java keytool is available from the Java JRE or JDK,
    • the Keystore Explorer is an open source utility to graphically manage certificate stores.
  • Starting from Java 9 the PKCS12 keystore type is default and is not required to be specified with keytool.
  • The following sections assume a PKCS12 keystore/truststore format. For Unix OS the .p12 file extension frequently is used, for Windows OS the .pfx extension is preferably used. Both file extensions indicate the same PKCS12 format and can be used interchangeably.

Certificate Management

Private keys Keys and certificates Certificates should be distributed as follows:

...

  • Keystore and truststore shown in orange are required for any connections of JOC Cockpit to a Controller.
    • The Controller's private key Private Key and certificate Certificate for Server Authentication are added to the Controller's keystore.
    • The Root CA Certificate is added to the Controller's truststore.
  • The keystore and truststore shown in green are required if mutual authentication is in place for certificate based client authentication (default).
  • The Controller's truststore shown in green is required should secure connections be used by a Controller to access Agents. It is therefore recommended the Controller's truststore is set up.
  • Similar certificate management applies for any additional standby JOC Cockpit instances acting in a cluster.

...

...

  • On the Controller instance's server create the keystore using openssl and the keytool from your Java JRE or JDK or a third 3rd-party utility.
    • For use with a third 3rd-party utility create a keystore, e.g. https-keystore.p12, in PKCS12 format and import:
      • Controller private key Private Key and certificate Certificate for Server Authentication
    • For use with openssl and keytool create the keystore with the private key Private Key and certificate Certificate for Server Authentication from the command line. The examples below show a possible approach for certificate management - however, there are other ways of achieving similar results.
      • Example for importing a private key Private Key and CA-signed certificate Certificate to a PKCS12 keystore:

        Code Block
        languagebash
        titleExample how to import a private key Private Key and CA-signed certificate Certificate to a PKCS12 keystore
        # Assume the fully qualified domain name (FQDN) of the Controller server to be "controller.example.com"
        
        # If the Controller's CA-signed certificateCertificate is provided from a pkcs12 keystore (certificate.p12), extract the certificateCertificate to a .crt file in PEM format (controller.example.com.crt)
        # openssl pkcs12 -in certificate.p12 -nokeys -out controller.example.com.crt
        
        # Import the Controller's privatePrivate keyKey (controller.example.com.key) and certificateCertificate (controller.example.com.crt) from PEM format to a new keystore keystore (controller.example.com.(https-keystore.p12)
        openssl pkcs12 -export -in controller.example.com.crt -inkey controller.example.com.key --name controller.example.com -out "JS7_CONTROLLER_CONFIG_DIR/private/https-keystore.p12"
      • Example for creating a private key Private Key and selfCA-signed certificate Certificate and import to a keystore

        • Refer to examples available from JS7 - How to create self-signed X.509 SSL TLS Certificates, chapter Creating a SSL/TLS Server CertificateCertificates.

          Code Block
          languagebash
          titleExample how to create a private key Private Key and selfCA-signed certificateCertificate
          # Creating the privatePrivate keyKey and selfCA-signed certificateCertificate for the given validity period
          ./create_server_certificate.sh --dns=controller.example.com --days=365
        • Refer to examples available from JS7 - How to add SSL TLS Certificates to Keystore and Truststore.

          Code Block
          titleExample how to add a private key Private Key and selfCA-signed certificate Certificate to a PKCS12 keystore
          # Adding the privatePrivate keyKey and certificateCertificate to a keystore
          ./js7_create_certificate_store.sh \
              --keystore=JS7_CONTROLLER_CONFIG_DIR/private/https-keystore.p12 \
              --key=controller.example.com.key \
              --cert=controller.example.com.crt \
              --alias=controller.example.com \
              --password="jobscheduler"


          When using additional arguments for creation of a truststore then users have the truststore available for the later step 4:

          Code Block
          titleExample how to add a private key Private Key and selfCA-signed certificate Certificate to a PKCS12 keystore and the Root CA Certificate to a truststore
          # Adding the privatePrivate keyKey and certificateCertificate to a keystore and Root CA Certificate to a truststore
          ./js7_create_certificate_store.sh \
              --keystore=JS7_CONTROLLER_CONFIG_DIR/private/https-keystore.p12 \
              --truststore=JS7_CONTROLLER_CONFIG_DIR/private/https-truststore.p12 \ 
              --key=controller.example.com.key \
              --cert=controller.example.com.crt \
              --alias=controller.example.com \
              --password="jobscheduler" \
              --ca-root=root-ca.crt
    • With the keystore being set up, specify the relevant properties with the JS7_CONTROLLER_CONFIG_DIR/private/private.conf configuration file:
      • Example

        Code Block
        languagetext
        titleExample for private.conf file specifying the Controller keystore
        js7 {
            web {
                # keystore location for https connections
                https {
                    keystore {
                        # Default: ${js7.config-directory}"/private/https-keystore.p12"
                        file=${js7.config-directory}"/private/https-keystore.p12"
                        key-password="jobscheduler"
                        store-password="jobscheduler"
                    }
                }
            }
        }


        Explanation:
        • js7.web.https.keystore.file is used for the path to the keystore.
        • js7.web.https.keystore.key-password is used for access to the private keyPrivate Key.
        • js7.web.https.keystore.store-password is used for access to the keystore. Passwords for private key Private Key and keystore have to match when using PKCS12 keystores.

  • On the Controller instance's server create the truststore using the keytool from your Java JRE or JDK or a third 3rd-party utility.
    • For use with a third 3rd-party utility create a truststore, e.g. https-truststore.p12, in PKCS12 format and import:
      • Root CA Certificate
    • The examples below show a possible approach for certificate management - however, there are other ways of achieving similar results.
      • Example for importing a Root CA Certificate to a PKCS12 truststore:

        Code Block
        languagebash
        titleExample how to import a Root CA Certificate to a PKCS12 truststore
        # Import Root CA Certificate in PEM format to a PKCS12 truststore (https-truststore.p12)
        keytool -importcert -alias "root-ca" -file "root-ca.crt" -keystore "JS7_CONTROLLER_CONFIG_DIR/private/https-truststore.p12" -storetype PKCS12

...

  • On the JOC Cockpit server create the truststore using the keytool from your Java JRE or JDK or a third 3rd-party utility.
    • For use with a third 3rd-party utility create a truststore, e.g. https-truststore.p12, in PKCS12 format and import:
      • Root CA Certificate
    • For use with keytool create the truststore in PKCS12 or JKS format with the Root CA Certificate. The examples below show a possible approach for certificate management - however, there are other ways how to achieve similar results.
      • Example showing how to import a Root CA Certificate to a PKCS12 truststore:

        Code Block
        languagebash
        titleExample how to import a Root CA Certificate into a PKCS12 truststore
        # import Root CA Certificate in PEM format to a PKCS12 truststore (https-truststore.p12)
        keytool -importcert -alias "root-ca" -file "root-ca.crt" -keystore "JETTY_BASE/resources/joc/https-truststore.p12" -storetype PKCS12
  • The location of the truststore is added to the JETTY_BASE/resources/joc/joc.properties configuration file like this:

    • Example for a PKCS12 truststore

      Code Block
      languagetext
      titleExample how to specify a PKCS12 truststore location with the joc.properties file
      ### Location of the truststore that contains the certificates of all
      ###   Controllers used with HTTPS connections. The path can be absolute or
      ###   relative to joc.properties
      
      truststore_path = https-truststore.p12 
      truststore_type = PKCS12
      truststore_password = jobscheduler
    • Example for a JKS truststore

      Code Block
      languagetext
      titleExample how to specify a JKS truststore location with the joc.properties file
      collapsetrue
      ### Location of the truststore that contains the certificates of all
      ###   Controllers used with HTTPS connections. The path can be absolute or 
      ###   relative to joc.properties
      
      truststore_path = https-truststore.jks
      truststore_type = JKS
      truststore_password = jobscheduler
  • Hostname verification by default is in place with the JETTY_BASE/resources/joc/joc.properties configuration file.

    Code Block
    titleExample how to specify hostname verification with the joc.properties file
    ################################################################################
    ### Specifies if hostname verification should be carried out for HTTPS connections.
    ### Default true
    
    https_with_hostname_verification = true

...

For mutual authentication JOC Cockpit has to hold a Client Authentication private key Private Key and certificate Certificate in its keystore.

  • This can be simplified by the use of a private keyPrivate Key/certificate Certificate pair that is created for both extended key usages Server Authentication and Client Authentication. In this case a single private key Private Key and certificate Certificate is stored with the JOC Cockpit's keystore as described in the the JS7 - JOC Cockpit HTTPS Connections article.
  • If separate private keyPrivate Key/certificate Certificate pairs for Server Authentication and Client Authentication purposes are used then use of separate certificate stores for the JOC Cockpit is recommended:
    • The keystore holds the private keyPrivate Key/certificate Certificate for Server Authentication. The location of the keystore is configured with JETTY_BASE/start.ini.
    • The client keystore holds the private key/certificate holds the Private Key/Certificate for Client Authentication. The location of the client keystore is configured with with JETTY_BASE/resources/joc/joc.properties.

...

  • On the JOC Cockpit server create the client keystore using the keytool from your Java JRE or JDK or a third 3rd-party utility.
    • For use with a 3rd-party utility create a client keystore, e.g. https-client-keystore.p12, in PKCS12 format and import:
      • the JOC Cockpit private key and certificate for Client Private Key and Certificate for Client Authentication
    • For use with keytool create the client keystore in PKCS12 or JKS format according to the steps indicated with JS7 - JOC Cockpit HTTPS Connections: Step 2: Create JOC Cockpit Keystore chapter.
      • Apply the steps indicated to the client keystore and use the private keyPrivate Key/certificate Certificate pair for Client Authentication.
  • The location of the client keystore is added to the JETTY_BASE/resources/joc/joc.properties configuration file like this:

    • Example for a PKCS12 client keystore:

      Code Block
      languagetext
      titleExample how to specify the PKCS12 client keystore location with joc.properties file
      ### Location of the client keystore that contains the private key and 
      ###   certificate for JOC Cockpit client authentication relative to
      ###   joc.properties
      
      keystore_path = https-client-keystore.p12 
      keystore_type = PKCS12
      keystore_password = jobscheduler
    • Example for a JKS client keystore:

      Code Block
      languagetext
      titleExample how to specify the JKS client keystore location with joc.properties file
      collapsetrue
      ### Location of the client keystore that contains the private key and 
      ###   certificate for JOC Cockpit client authentication relative to
      ###   joc.properties
      
      keystore_path = https-client-keystore.jks
      keystore_type = JKS
      keystore_password = jobscheduler
Show If
matchall
userap

Risk Mitigation

The descriptions above indicate use of a Root CA Certificate for verification of Client Authentication certificates when it comes to mutual authentication.

  • In fact use of a Root CA Certificate allows any clients with a Client Authentication certificate signed by the same Root CA or Intermediate CA to be authenticated. This implication might allow an unwanted number of clients to access a Controller. By design the only clients to access a Controller should be JOC Cockpit instances.
  • Coping strategies include:
    • using a separate certificate authority Certificate Authority to sign Client Authentication certificates for access to Controllers.
    • importing individual Client Authentication certificates to the Controller's truststore instead of using a Root CA Certificate.

...

  • A restart of the relevant product is required to apply modifications changes to either the the Controller JS7_CONFIG_DIR/private/private.conf file or to JOC Cockpit configuration files.

...

Resources

...